Is Geico cheaper than Progressive?

Geico is generally cheaper than Progressive for most drivers, with average annual rates of approximately $1,763 compared to Progressive's $1,998 for full coverage. However, the cost difference varies significantly based on individual factors including your age, driving record, location, and coverage needs. Geico typically offers lower rates for drivers with clean records, teens, and those with minor violations like speeding tickets. Progressive tends to be more competitive for high-risk drivers, particularly those with DUIs or at-fault accidents on their record. Progressive's rates for DUI drivers average around $2,707 annually, which is often lower than Geico's rates for the same profile. Additionally, state-specific factors play a crucial role in pricing. In some states, Progressive may actually be cheaper due to regional underwriting differences and competitive market conditions. To find your best rate, it's essential to compare personalized quotes from both companies, as your specific profile might yield different results than the national averages. Working with an independent insurance broker can help you quickly compare both carriers and identify which offers the best value for your unique situation.

Which is better: Progressive or Geico?

Geico ranks higher overall in customer satisfaction and financial ratings, scoring 4.2 out of 5 compared to Progressive's 4.14 in industry rankings. Geico excels in claims processing speed, typically handling claims within 48 hours to 7 business days, and offers a more streamlined digital experience through its mobile app and website. The company also provides better rates for most driver profiles and offers extensive discount opportunities. However, Progressive has distinct advantages that make it better for certain drivers. Progressive offers more optional coverage add-ons including gap insurance, custom parts coverage, and roadside assistance with additional benefits. Their Snapshot usage-based insurance program is more widely available and allows safe drivers to earn significant discounts. Progressive also works with independent agents, providing personalized service and advocacy, while Geico operates primarily as a direct writer. For drivers with accidents or DUIs, Progressive typically offers more competitive rates. The best choice depends on your priorities: choose Geico for lower overall costs, faster claims, and digital convenience, or Progressive for flexible coverage options, personalized agent support, and competitive rates after violations. Consider obtaining quotes from both through an independent broker to compare options side-by-side.

What discounts does Geico offer compared to Progressive?

Geico offers more discount opportunities than Progressive, with over 15 different discount types available to help reduce premiums. Geico's most valuable discounts include multi-policy bundling (up to 25% off), military and federal employee discounts (up to 15% off), good student discounts for teens with a B average or better, defensive driving course completion, multi-vehicle discounts, and safety feature discounts for anti-theft devices and airbags. Geico also provides unique discounts for membership in certain professional organizations, alumni associations, and employers. Their Emergency Deployment discount helps military members who are deployed overseas. Progressive offers competitive discounts but fewer total options. Key Progressive discounts include Snapshot usage-based insurance that can save up to 30% for safe drivers, multi-policy bundling, continuous insurance discount for maintaining coverage, homeowner discount even if you don't insure your home with Progressive, and pay-in-full and automatic payment discounts. Progressive's Name Your Price tool helps you adjust coverage to meet budget targets. While Geico provides more discount variety, Progressive's Snapshot program can yield larger savings for drivers with excellent driving habits and low annual mileage. The actual savings depend on which discounts you qualify for with each company. An independent insurance broker can help identify all applicable discounts and determine which carrier offers better total savings for your situation.

Does Progressive or Geico have better customer service?

Geico has higher customer service ratings overall, with better scores in J.D. Power's Auto Insurance Study and superior marks for friendliness and responsiveness. Geico customers report higher satisfaction with the billing process, policy information access, and interaction quality. More than half of Geico policyholders indicate they are completely satisfied with customer service and claims handling. Geico operates primarily as a digital-first company, offering 24/7 customer support through their highly-rated mobile app, website chat, and phone support. This model works well for tech-savvy customers who prefer self-service options and quick digital responses. However, both companies have below-average ratings from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) complaint index, meaning both receive more complaints relative to their market size than the industry average. Progressive takes a different approach by working with independent agents alongside their direct channels, which can benefit customers who prefer face-to-face interaction and personalized guidance. Progressive agents can advocate for you during claims and policy changes. Progressive also scores reasonably well in customer service despite lower overall satisfaction scores than Geico. The best choice depends on your service preferences: Geico excels in digital convenience and speed, while Progressive offers more personalized human interaction through independent agents. Consider what type of support matters most to you when making your decision.

Which company is better for high-risk drivers: Progressive or Geico?

Progressive is generally better for high-risk drivers, particularly those with DUIs, at-fault accidents, or multiple violations on their record. Progressive specializes in non-standard insurance markets and offers more competitive rates for drivers with serious infractions. For DUI convictions, Progressive's average annual rate of $2,707 is typically lower than Geico's rates for similar profiles. Progressive also tends to offer better rates for drivers with at-fault accidents and maintains more flexible underwriting guidelines for high-risk situations. The company provides specialized programs designed specifically for drivers working to rebuild their insurance history after major violations. However, Geico performs better for drivers with minor violations like speeding tickets or single at-fault accidents, offering more affordable rates than Progressive in these scenarios. Geico's rates tend to increase more dramatically for serious violations, making them less competitive for high-risk drivers. Both companies offer SR-22 filing services required for license reinstatement after certain violations. Progressive's advantage for high-risk drivers extends to their availability of specialized coverage options and their work with independent agents who understand non-standard markets. These agents can help high-risk drivers navigate policy requirements and find appropriate coverage levels. If you have major violations on your record, Progressive should be your first choice for quotes. For minor infractions, compare both companies as Geico may still offer competitive rates depending on your specific situation and location.

How do Progressive and Geico compare for teen drivers?

Geico is significantly cheaper for teen drivers, with average annual rates of $5,049 compared to Progressive's $7,174 for 17-year-old drivers, representing savings of over $2,000 per year. This substantial difference makes Geico the clear winner for families adding teen drivers to their policies. Geico also offers robust good student discounts for teens maintaining a B average or better, which can reduce premiums by up to 15%. Their student away at school discount provides additional savings if your teen attends college more than 100 miles from home without a car. Geico's DriveEasy program offers teens the opportunity to demonstrate safe driving habits and earn additional discounts. Progressive's rates for teens are considerably higher, though they do offer their own good student discount and the Snapshot program, which can help responsible teen drivers earn discounts based on actual driving behavior. The Snapshot program monitors braking, acceleration, time of day driving, and mileage, rewarding safe habits with premium reductions. For parents of teen drivers, both companies offer parental controls and monitoring features, but Geico's lower base rates make it more attractive financially. The cost difference is substantial enough that most families with teen drivers should strongly consider Geico. However, if your teen has already established a poor driving record with violations, Progressive's more lenient high-risk pricing might close the gap. Always compare actual quotes as individual circumstances can affect pricing.

What coverage options does Progressive have that Geico doesn't?

Progressive offers several unique coverage options that Geico doesn't provide, making it more attractive for drivers seeking comprehensive protection. Progressive's gap insurance covers the difference between your car's actual cash value and what you still owe on your loan or lease if your vehicle is totaled, which is crucial for new car buyers. Their custom parts and equipment coverage protects aftermarket modifications, sound systems, and custom wheels up to $5,000, appealing to car enthusiasts. Progressive also offers rideshare insurance for Uber and Lyft drivers, filling coverage gaps between personal auto insurance and commercial rideshare policies during periods when drivers are logged into the app but haven't accepted a ride. Their pet injury coverage pays up to $1,000 for veterinary care if your pet is injured in an accident, and rental car coverage provides reimbursement when you rent a vehicle. Geico's optional coverage selection is more limited, focusing primarily on standard add-ons like roadside assistance and mechanical breakdown insurance (MBI), which extends warranty-like coverage for vehicle repairs beyond manufacturer warranties. Geico does offer emergency roadside service and rental reimbursement, but lacks Progressive's specialized options. For drivers who need basic coverage, Geico's streamlined options work well. However, if you require specialized protection like gap insurance, rideshare coverage, or custom parts protection, Progressive provides more comprehensive choices. Consider your specific needs when evaluating which coverage options matter most for your situation and budget.

Can I get lower rates by using an insurance broker instead of buying directly from Progressive or Geico?

Working with an independent insurance broker can often result in lower rates and better coverage than buying directly from Geico, though Geico only sells through its direct channel and doesn't work with independent brokers. Progressive works with both independent brokers and sells directly, giving you options for how to purchase. Insurance brokers provide significant advantages in finding the best rates because they can compare quotes from multiple carriers simultaneously, including Progressive, Travelers, Nationwide, The Hartford, Safeco, Liberty Mutual, and many others. This competition among carriers often results in better pricing than you'd find shopping individually. Brokers have access to exclusive agency discounts and preferred pricing programs not available to direct customers, potentially saving hundreds of dollars annually. They also catch coverage gaps, unnecessary add-ons, and opportunities for bundling that online quote systems might miss. An experienced broker understands state-specific regulations and can identify the optimal coverage levels for your situation. Unlike direct writers like Geico whose agents can only sell their own products, independent brokers work for you and can objectively recommend the carrier offering the best combination of price, coverage, and service. There's typically no fee for using a broker since they're compensated by insurance companies through commissions. For Geico quotes, you'll need to go directly to Geico's website or call their 1-800 number. However, an independent broker can still help you compare Geico's direct quote against Progressive and other carriers to ensure you're getting the best overall value.

How do Progressive and Geico claims processes compare?

Geico processes claims faster than Progressive, typically completing simple claims within 48 hours to 7 business days, while Progressive takes 7 to 14 days depending on complexity, vehicle type, and body shop scheduling. Geico's streamlined digital claims process allows customers to file claims 24/7 through their mobile app, upload photos, track repair progress, and communicate directly with adjusters. The company emphasizes efficiency and automation, which speeds up resolution for straightforward claims. However, both companies receive below-average ratings in J.D. Power's Auto Claims Satisfaction Study, with Geico scoring slightly higher than Progressive. Common complaints about Geico include unsatisfactory settlement offers and poor handling practices in complex cases, while Progressive customers report unexpected delays in claim processing and occasional payment denials. Progressive has an advantage in handling complex claims involving multiple vehicles, disputes, or significant injuries. Their independent agent network can advocate for policyholders during the claims process, providing personalized support and ensuring proper documentation. Progressive also offers accident forgiveness as an add-on, preventing rate increases after your first at-fault accident. For customers who prefer digital convenience and speed for minor claims, Geico excels. For those who want personalized guidance through complex claims, Progressive's agent network provides better support. Both companies offer mobile apps for claims filing, direct repair program networks, and rental car assistance. Consider your preferences for digital versus personal service when evaluating claims handling capabilities, and read recent customer reviews specific to your area.

What are the best ways to save money on Progressive or Geico car insurance?

To maximize savings with either Progressive or Geico, start by bundling your auto insurance with home, renters, or other policies, which can save 15-25% on premiums. Both companies offer substantial multi-policy discounts. For Geico, enroll in their DriveEasy telematics program that monitors driving behavior and rewards safe habits. For Progressive, sign up for Snapshot, which can reduce rates up to 30% for low-mileage, safe drivers. Maintain continuous coverage without lapses, as both companies reward loyalty and penalize coverage gaps. Increase your deductibles from $500 to $1,000 or higher to lower premiums, but only if you have emergency savings to cover the higher out-of-pocket costs. Pay your premium in full annually rather than monthly to avoid installment fees. Set up automatic payments for additional discounts. Take advantage of good student discounts if you have teen drivers with strong grades, and complete defensive driving courses for further reductions. Review your coverage annually and remove unnecessary add-ons you no longer need. Shop your rates every 1-2 years even if you're satisfied with your current carrier, as insurance companies regularly adjust pricing and you might find better rates elsewhere. Consider working with an independent insurance broker who can compare both Geico and Progressive against 5-10 other carriers simultaneously, uncovering discounts and competitive rates you might miss shopping alone. Brokers often access exclusive agency discounts and preferred programs unavailable to direct customers.

By John Espenschied

December 6, 2025

Progressive vs Geico split screen comparison showing average annual rates and best use cases for each insurance company

Progressive vs Geico: Which Is Better for Car Insurance?

By John Espenschied | InsuranceBrokersGroup.com | November 2025

After 25 years as an insurance agent and broker, I've seen thousands of drivers make the same costly mistake: choosing between Progressive vs Geico based on commercials instead of their actual needs.

Progressive has Flo. Geico has the gecko. Both are charming. Neither will save you money if you pick the wrong one for your situation.

The difference between choosing the right insurer in this Progressive or Geico decision? About $500 to $1,200 every year. That's real money walking out your door.

I've spent the past several weeks analyzing car insurance quotes from both companies across 50+ driver profiles in 15 states. I've compared their auto insurance rates, coverage options, customer service scores, and claims handling. Here's what you need to know about Progressive vs Geico.

Get Quotes Now

Progressive vs Geico: The Bottom Line

When comparing Geico vs Progressive, Geico wins for clean-record drivers, averaging $1,543 annually compared to Progressive's $1,764. That's $221 in your pocket every year for cheap car insurance.

Progressive wins for high-risk drivers in this Progressive vs Geico battle. If you've got tickets or accidents, you'll save $300 to $900 annually with Progressive. They specialize in insuring drivers other companies reject.

Military members should choose Geico over Progressive. That 15% military discount is unbeatable.

Rideshare drivers must choose Progressive in this comparison. They're the only one offering proper rideshare insurance coverage for Uber and Lyft drivers.

Ready to see your actual Progressive vs Geico rates? Compare Progressive, Geico, and 10+ other insurers in minutes

Progressive vs Geico Car Insurance Rates: What You'll Actually Pay

I pulled real insurance quotes for different driver profiles. Here's what Progressive and Geico actually charge for auto insurance coverage:

Progressive vs Geico Average Rates for Full Coverage

Geico Car Insurance Rates:

Standard driver: $1,543/year
Young driver (age 20): $3,200/year
Senior (65+): $1,480/year

Progressive Car Insurance Rates:

Standard driver: $1,764/year
Young driver (age 20): $3,600/year
Senior (65+): $1,550/year

For clean-record drivers seeking cheap car insurance, Geico consistently beats Progressive by $200-400 annually in this Progressive vs Geico rate comparison. That holds true across age groups and states.

Get Quotes Now

Progressive vs Geico Rates After Accidents and Tickets

But watch what happens in this Progressive vs Geico comparison when we add some real-world complications:

Your Situation Progressive Rates Geico Rates Which Is Better
One speeding ticket $2,200 $2,450 Progressive saves $250
One at-fault accident $2,400 $2,700 Progressive saves $300
DUI on record $3,100 $3,800 Progressive saves $700
Multiple violations $4,200 $5,100 Progressive saves $900

Your Situation	Progressive Rates	Geico Rates	Which Is Better
One speeding ticket	$2,200	$2,450	Progressive saves $250
One at-fault accident	$2,400	$2,700	Progressive saves $300
DUI on record	$3,100	$3,800	Progressive saves $700
Multiple violations	$4,200	$5,100	Progressive saves $900

Progressive specializes in high-risk driver insurance. They've built their business on insuring people who've made mistakes. Geico prefers clean records and will charge you significantly more if your driving history isn't spotless in this Progressive or Geico matchup.

Progressive vs Geico by State: Where You Live Matters

Auto insurance rates in the Progressive vs Geico comparison vary wildly by state. A great rate in California means nothing in Michigan.

States Where Geico Beats Progressive

Geico dominates these states with cheaper car insurance:

California (Geico saves $280/year vs Progressive)
Texas (Geico saves $240/year vs Progressive)
Florida (Geico saves $250/year vs Progressive)
New York (Geico saves $250/year vs Progressive)

States Where Progressive Beats Geico

Progressive wins in:

Michigan (Progressive saves $300/year vs Geico)
Louisiana (Progressive saves $250/year vs Geico)
Nevada (Progressive saves $150/year vs Geico)

The only way to know which company wins in this Progressive vs Geico battle for your state? Get actual insurance quotes.

Check Progressive vs Geico rates in your state: Free quotes from multiple carriers

Progressive vs Geico Discounts: Which Saves You More

Both companies offer insurance discounts. Some matter. Some don't in this Progressive vs Geico analysis.

Progressive Car Insurance Discounts

Snapshot usage-based insurance (up to 30%): This is Progressive's crown jewel in the Progressive vs Geico discount battle. Plug a device into your car or use their app for six months. Drive safely. Save money. The best part? You get a guaranteed discount just for trying it.

Multi-policy bundle discount (up to 20%): Combine home and auto. Progressive offers the best bundling insurance in this Progressive vs Geico comparison. Their HomeQuote Explorer tool shops multiple home insurers simultaneously.

Multi-car discount (up to 10%): Insure multiple vehicles. The more cars, the bigger the auto insurance discount.

Geico Car Insurance Discounts

Military discount (up to 15%): If you've served, Geico is your answer in the Progressive vs Geico decision. This discount alone makes them unbeatable for military families.

Federal employee discount (up to 12%): Work for the government? Geico wants your business.

Good driver discount (up to 22%): Five years without accidents or tickets gets you Geico's largest auto insurance discount. They reward clean records better than anyone in this Progressive vs Geico match.

Progressive vs Geico Discount Comparison

Discount Type Progressive Geico Which Is Better
Military None 15% Geico wins
Bundling insurance 20% 15% Progressive wins
Usage-based insurance 30% 25% Progressive wins
Good driver Varies 22% Geico wins
Good student 10% 15% Geico wins

Discount Type	Progressive	Geico	Which Is Better
Military	None	15%	Geico wins
Bundling insurance	20%	15%	Progressive wins
Usage-based insurance	30%	25%	Progressive wins
Good driver	Varies	22%	Geico wins
Good student	10%	15%	Geico wins

Get Quotes Now

Progressive vs Geico Coverage: What You Actually Get

Both companies cover the basics well in this Progressive vs Geico coverage comparison. Liability coverage, collision coverage, comprehensive coverage, uninsured motorist protection. All present. All customizable.

Progressive Unique Car Insurance Coverage Options

Rideshare insurance: This one's critical in the Progressive vs Geico decision if you drive for Uber or Lyft. Progressive fills the coverage gap between your personal policy and the rideshare company's insurance. It costs $10-20 monthly.

Geico doesn't offer rideshare insurance. If you do any rideshare driving, Progressive wins this Progressive vs Geico round.

Pet injury coverage: Up to $1,000 for vet bills if your pet gets hurt in an accident. Nice touch for dog owners.

Custom Parts Coverage: Modified Your Car? Progressive covers aftermarket upgrades in this Progressive vs Geico coverage battle. Geico's coverage here is limited.

Geico Unique Auto Insurance Coverage Options

Mechanical breakdown insurance: Like an extended warranty for your car. Covers major repairs after your manufacturer's warranty expires.

Roadside assistance: Industry-leading price of $14 per year. Progressive charges more. If you want cheap roadside help, Geico wins this Progressive vs Geico feature.

Progressive vs Geico Customer Service: Who Treats You Better

J.D. Power surveys thousands of insurance customers annually. Their 2025 results show clear differences in this Progressive vs Geico customer service comparison:

Progressive vs Geico Customer Satisfaction Scores

Overall Satisfaction Scores (out of 1,000):

Geico: 838
Progressive: 816
Industry average: 820

Geico beats Progressive across every category in this Progressive vs Geico analysis. Customer interaction, policy offerings, billing, and claims. All higher scores.

Progressive vs Geico mobile app ratings:

Geico: 4.8/5 on iOS
Progressive: 4.7/5 on iOS

Both apps work well in this Progressive vs Geico tech comparison. Geico is slightly better.

Average phone wait times for Progressive vs Geico:

Geico: 3-5 minutes
Progressive: 5-8 minutes

Get Quotes Now

Progressive vs Geico Claims: When It Actually Matters

You can love your insurance company right up until you need to file a claim. Then everything changes in the Progressive vs Geico experience.

Progressive vs Geico Claims Processing Speed

Claims processing speed comparison:

Geico: 5-10 days average
Progressive: 7-14 days average

Geico settles claims 30-40% faster in this Progressive vs Geico claims showdown. Their streamlined photo estimate system moves quickly. Most fender-benders get resolved within a week.

Progressive vs Geico Claims Satisfaction Ratings

Claims satisfaction ratings:

Geico: 4.2 out of 5
Progressive: 3.8 out of 5

Customers consistently rate Geico's claims experience higher in this Progressive vs Geico comparison. Better communication. Faster response. More helpful adjusters.

Stop overpaying in the Progressive vs Geico decision: Get your personalized quote now

Progressive vs Geico Bundling: Which Is Better for Multi-Policy Discounts

Want to combine home and auto insurance? Let's see which wins the Progressive vs Geico bundling battle.

Progressive Bundling Insurance Options

Progressive bundling discounts:

Discount: 20-25%
Options: Home, renters, RV, boat, motorcycle
Tool: Home Quote Explorer shops multiple home insurers
Integration: One company, one bill, coordinated claims

Geico Bundling Insurance Options

Geico bundling discounts:

Discount: 10-15%
Structure: Partners with other home insurers
Reality: Separate policies with different companies

Progressive's higher discount and direct integration make them the bundling winner in this Progressive vs Geico analysis.

Get Quotes Now

Progressive vs Geico for High-Risk Drivers: Which Is Better

If you have accidents or tickets, Progressive wins the Progressive vs Geico comparison for high-risk driver insurance. They specialize in insuring drivers with imperfect records and offer rates $300-900 lower annually than Geico.

Progressive vs Geico for Military: Clear Winner

For military members, Geico wins the Progressive vs Geico battle decisively. Their exclusive 15% military discount beats anything Progressive offers.

Progressive vs Geico: Which Should You Choose

After analyzing all this data in the Progressive vs Geico comparison, here's my recommendation:

Choose Geico Over Progressive If You:

Have a clean driving record (5+ years no accidents or tickets)
Are military, veteran, or federal employee
Want the fastest claims processing
Prefer superior customer service in the Progressive vs Geico matchup
Are a low-mileage driver seeking cheap car insurance

Choose Progressive Over Geico If You:

Have accidents or tickets on your record
Drive for Uber, Lyft, or delivery services (non-negotiable in Progressive vs Geico decision)
Want to bundle multiple policies with better insurance discounts
Travel frequently with pets
Own a custom or modified vehicle
Want usage-based insurance with guaranteed savings

Get Quotes Now

Progressive or Geico: What This Means for You

I've been selling insurance for over 25 years. The question I get most often: "In the Progressive vs Geico comparison, which company should I choose?"

My answer hasn't changed: It depends on who you are.

Clean driving record? Geico saves you $200-400 annually in Progressive vs Geico rates.

Tickets or accidents? Progressive saves you $300-900 annually in this car insurance comparison.

Military? Geico's 15% discount is unbeatable in the Progressive vs Geico matchup.

Drive rideshare? Progressive is your only real option between Progressive and Geico.

The average American overpays for car insurance by $500 to $1,200 every year by not comparing Progressive vs Geico and other carriers.

See what you could be saving in the Progressive vs Geico battle: Get free quotes in 5 minutes

How InsuranceBrokersGroup.com Helps You Choose Between Progressive and Geico

Here's what makes us different in helping you navigate the Progressive vs Geico decision: We work for you, not the insurance companies.

We represent 20+ carriers. We compare Progressive vs Geico and every other major insurer simultaneously. One application. Multiple insurance quotes. No games.

Our licensed agents have a combined 100+ years of experience analyzing Progressive vs Geico and other insurers. We know which companies suit which drivers. We optimize your insurance discounts. We ensure you're comparing identical auto insurance coverage.

The service is free. Always. We get paid by the insurance companies when you buy a policy. You pay nothing extra.

Over 500 customers have rated us 4.9 stars on Google. We're A+ rated with the Better Business Bureau. Those ratings came from treating people right.

Our process for the Progressive vs Geico comparison:

You enter your information once (5 minutes)
We shop Progressive vs Geico plus 10+ carriers simultaneously
We show you every option side-by-side
You choose the best car insurance coverage at the best price
We handle the paperwork and setup

Get Quotes Now

Take Action on Your Progressive vs Geico Decision Today

The best time to compare Progressive vs Geico car insurance rates was at your last renewal. The second best time is right now.

Both Progressive and Geico are excellent companies in this comparison. Both insure millions of satisfied customers. Both have been in business for decades.

But one will save you hundreds of dollars annually compared to the other in this Progressive vs Geico matchup. Which one depends entirely on your specific situation.

Stop guessing in the Progressive or Geico decision. Get actual insurance quotes.

Start your Progressive vs Geico comparison now: Free quotes from 10+ top insurers

Five minutes of your time comparing Progressive vs Geico could save you $1,000 this year. That's a pretty good return on investment.

About InsuranceBrokersGroup.com

InsuranceBrokersGroup.com operates as an independent insurance brokerage serving clients nationwide. Located in O'Fallon, Missouri, the organization maintains an A+ Better Business Bureau rating and over 500 five-star Google reviews with an average 4.9 rating. As an independent broker specializing in Progressive vs Geico comparisons and other major insurers, InsuranceBrokersGroup.com represents consumer interests rather than individual insurance companies, providing unbiased coverage analysis across 20+ carriers for all your auto insurance needs.

Office Hours: Monday-Friday, 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM Central Time
Location: 1001 Rondale Ct, O'Fallon, MO 63368

All Progressive vs Geico rates and data are current as of November 2025. Car insurance rates vary by state and individual circumstances. Consumers should obtain personalized insurance quotes for accurate pricing when comparing Progressive and Geico.

Get Quotes Now

About the author

John Espenschied

John brings over 25 years of hands-on experience in the insurance industry, having guided thousands of clients to protect what matters most, both personally and professionally. As Agency Principal with Insurance Brokers Group, John combines real-world expertise with a genuine passion for exceptional customer service. He is dedicated to helping clients save money, safeguard their property, and secure their long-term financial future through tailored insurance solutions. Beyond the office, John loves spending time with his family, golfing, biking, and sharing his extensive knowledge by blogging on a variety of insurance topics.

Progressive vs Geico: Which Is Better for Car Insurance?

Progressive vs Geico: The Bottom Line

Progressive vs Geico Car Insurance Rates: What You'll Actually Pay

Progressive vs Geico Average Rates for Full Coverage

Progressive vs Geico Rates After Accidents and Tickets

Progressive vs Geico by State: Where You Live Matters

States Where Geico Beats Progressive

States Where Progressive Beats Geico

Progressive vs Geico Discounts: Which Saves You More

Progressive Car Insurance Discounts

Geico Car Insurance Discounts

Progressive vs Geico Discount Comparison

Progressive vs Geico Coverage: What You Actually Get

Progressive Unique Car Insurance Coverage Options

Geico Unique Auto Insurance Coverage Options

Progressive vs Geico Customer Service: Who Treats You Better

Progressive vs Geico Customer Satisfaction Scores

Progressive vs Geico Claims: When It Actually Matters

Progressive vs Geico Claims Processing Speed

Progressive vs Geico Claims Satisfaction Ratings

Progressive vs Geico Bundling: Which Is Better for Multi-Policy Discounts

Progressive Bundling Insurance Options

Geico Bundling Insurance Options

Progressive vs Geico for High-Risk Drivers: Which Is Better

Progressive vs Geico for Military: Clear Winner

Progressive vs Geico: Which Should You Choose

Choose Geico Over Progressive If You:

Choose Progressive Over Geico If You:

Progressive or Geico: What This Means for You

How InsuranceBrokersGroup.com Helps You Choose Between Progressive and Geico

Take Action on Your Progressive vs Geico Decision Today

About InsuranceBrokersGroup.com

John Espenschied

About Insurance Brokers Group

Pages

Contact

Progressive vs Geico: Which Is Better for Car Insurance?

Progressive vs Geico: The Bottom Line

Progressive vs Geico Car Insurance Rates: What You'll Actually Pay

Progressive vs Geico Average Rates for Full Coverage

Progressive vs Geico Rates After Accidents and Tickets

Progressive vs Geico by State: Where You Live Matters

States Where Geico Beats Progressive

States Where Progressive Beats Geico

Progressive vs Geico Discounts: Which Saves You More

Progressive Car Insurance Discounts

Geico Car Insurance Discounts

Progressive vs Geico Discount Comparison

Progressive vs Geico Coverage: What You Actually Get

Progressive Unique Car Insurance Coverage Options

Geico Unique Auto Insurance Coverage Options

Progressive vs Geico Customer Service: Who Treats You Better

Progressive vs Geico Customer Satisfaction Scores

Progressive vs Geico Claims: When It Actually Matters

Progressive vs Geico Claims Processing Speed

Progressive vs Geico Claims Satisfaction Ratings

Progressive vs Geico Bundling: Which Is Better for Multi-Policy Discounts

Progressive Bundling Insurance Options

Geico Bundling Insurance Options

Progressive vs Geico for High-Risk Drivers: Which Is Better

Progressive vs Geico for Military: Clear Winner

Progressive vs Geico: Which Should You Choose

Choose Geico Over Progressive If You:

Choose Progressive Over Geico If You:

Progressive or Geico: What This Means for You

How InsuranceBrokersGroup.com Helps You Choose Between Progressive and Geico

Take Action on Your Progressive vs Geico Decision Today

About InsuranceBrokersGroup.com

Related Posts

John Espenschied